Saturday, December 6, 2014

CTE and NFL football

According to Boston University, Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) is a degenerative brain disease that is found commonly in individuals that have a history of repetitive brain trauma. This history can include brain injuries such as concussions. CTE is believed to be most frequently caused by numerous concussions, which is very prominent in football. In 2013,228 concussions were diagnosed in NFL (National Football League) players. In fact, there are on average around 9 concussions that happen per game. However, this does not include sub concussions, which are not commonly reported like “full” concussions are. Recently, researchers were prompted to examine the brains of 128 football players who have played football at least one level. This included individuals who played football at either the professional level, semi profession level, the college level, or the high school level. Of that sample, 101 of those players’ test results came back positive for the disease. In our discussion in class, football was compared to the gladiators in ancient Rome. I think that this is a very apt comparison. This disease is not nearly as prominent in the players of any other sport as it is in football players. Because of this, I believe that football should not be played. My primary reasoning is because 78.9 percent of all individuals who played football at any level and were tested came back positive for the disease. Professional football players are far worse off, with 96.2 percent of all former NFL players also being found to have this disease. An excuse that I have often heard by proponents of football is that the players should know how dangerous the sport is; that people who play football should know how dangerous the sport is and somehow agree to chance contracting this disease or any number of other debilitating brain disorders when they decide to play the game. Many attempts have been made to make the game safer, yet these have often been opposed. Those who oppose these safety changes often claim football cannot be made safer and still be considered the same game.  However, many officials also believe that changes need to be made to the way the game is play. For example, on January 14th 2014, a federal judge presiding over a lawsuit declined to approve a proposed 760 million dollar settlement on claims arising from concussions suffered by NFL players because she believed that the settlement was insufficient.

4 comments:

  1. I agree with Boston University that football is a cause for CTE. The numbers don't lie, and that is easy to see. The fact that the NFL dragged this case on for so long was for one reason and one reason only. That reason was to not lose millions of dollars. The NFL was in denial for fear that future players and parents would not allow themselves to participate in the sport that causes extreme damage to your brain. The NFL was afraid that this correlation between football and CTE would cost them money in the long run or even worse potentially end football all together. I understand why the NFL did what it did, but it was entirely wrong how they handled the situation. The NFL is at fault and deserves to have to pay former NFL players for the hardships brought upon them why they were in the league.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I obviously agree with Boston University's findings too. I also acknowledge that the National Football League did everything possible to cover up the connection with the sport and C.T.E. It is upsetting that the money from the lawsuit wasn't awarded... Of course, at what point did the NFL know the effects that constant trauma to the brain would cause. C.T.E. wasn't discovered until fairly recently so it is not as if now retired players were always being lied to. Of course, with how much money the NFL makes, they should be able to give their retirees proper healthcare benefits and assistance...with or without the existence of C.T.E. I agree that the NFL should be held liable to some degree, though I'm not sure the extent.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Boston University that Boston University causes CTE in players. I didn't like that they denied it and went on for so long saying it wasn't true when they had all the facts right in front of them. I feel like they lied so long that they started believing their own lies.

    ReplyDelete
  4. CTE is definitely caused by football, the constant head trauma. It is pretty obvious that constant head trauma by football isa cause. And i am happy that research is done by Boston University to get more knowledge about CTE. But what bugs me is the ignorance of the other medical professionals on CTE. I just do not understands why it seems that they don't seems to understand this issue.

    ReplyDelete