Friday, September 26, 2014

HIV and patient confidentiality


In class yesterday, we discussed a specific case where a HIV positive patient told her doctor that she was having unprotected sex and was not going to tell the partner. Some believed that patient confidentiality was more important, while others argued for the partner being told. I wanted to further elaborate on why physicians who have HIV positive patients with known sexual partners must tell the partner. If the physician does not tell the partner then he/she has the potential of infecting many others. The Hippocratic Oath says “first do no harm.” By not telling him/her that their sexual partner is HIV positive the physician is in fact doing harm. HIV is an epidemic with some of its origins involving HIV positive people having unprotected sex with some one else. If the sexual partners of these patients are not told about the risk then this pandemic will continue to grow exponentially because people will have unprotected sex never suspecting that they may be killing their partner. The best way to end this outbreak is by telling the unknowing sexual partners that the one they are sleeping with has HIV.

2 comments:

  1. For me, this truth-telling scenario was the hardest--to decide whether patient confidentiality or the safety of numerous people was more important. In the book, it states that the licensed psychologist's project was "designed to identify behavioral trends among HIV+ adults in the New York City area". Going into this project, would it not be safe to assume that one, if not more, of the HIV+ patients would admit to having unprotected sex? They felt comfortable only because of the informed consent form and the professionalism of the project and its doctors. As the psychologist, I would try to provide better knowledge of HIV/AIDS and safe sex practices rather than directly going to the boyfriend and putting the project, which could be very beneficial in the future, and my career at risk.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have to agree, as horrible as it would be to not tell the boyfriend and have potentially more people infected, it is not worth losing your job and your credibility as a psychologist. It is also not worth jeopardizing your study on the behavioral trends of HIV+ patients. Once you violate patient confidentiality, all of your hard work is instantly negated and the likelihood of you having another opportunity to conduct such an important study would be slim to none. If I were the psychologist, I would seriously consider talking with the patient and convinvincing her to notify her boyfriend of her serious medical condition. If you violate the patient confidentially agreement you also run the risk of being sued by your patient as well. The risks of telling her boyfriend are too great and quite frankly it is none of your business anyway. All you can do is try to help her realize that she should tell her boyfriend

    ReplyDelete