Informed Consent is the process by
which the treating health care provider discloses appropriate information to a
competent patient so that the patient may make a voluntary choice to accept or
refuse treatment. It originates from the legal and ethical right that the
patient has the right to say what happens to his or her body. An informed
consent can be said to have been given based upon a clear appreciation and
understanding of the facts, implications, and consequences of an action. In
order to give informed consent, the individual concerned must have adequate
reasoning faculties and be in possession of all relevant facts at the time
consent is given. The physician has to
involve the patient in their health care. It is usually in the parents’ rights
to decide what type of treatment their child or children receive. But there is
an exception to this doctors do have patient confidentiality for teens.
Confidentiality is defined as a
set of rules or a promise that limits access or places restrictions on certain
types of information. In so many words it means privacy. It means that when
you, as a young person from 12-17 years of age, talk with your health care
provider about certain issues like sex, drugs, and feelings, he or she does not
feel comfortable talking with parent or guardian about. Also, the doctor does
not tell your parents what you told them unless you give the physician permission.
So my question is should a doctor tell a parent if their patient has a STD. Sexually
transmitted diseases (STDs) are infections that can be transmitted through
sexual contact with an infected individual. These are also termed sexually
transmitted infections or STIs. STDs can be transmitted during vaginal or other
types of sexual intercourse including oral and anal sex.
For example there is this rare
case were a teen by the name of Jessica and she is 17 years old. Monday morning
she woke up with nausea. She goes to the restroom to vomit and she also has diarrhea.
She has to miss school because she can’t leave the bathroom. Her mom decides to
take her to the doctor because Jessica doesn’t look very well. They went to
their family’s personal health care physician and the mom told the doctor to
see if her daughter has a bad case food poisoning. The physician couldn’t
detect food poisoning so he gave her another test and he tells her that she has
HIV. Jessica told the family doctor she went to frat party 6 weeks ago and had
gotten really drunk that night and had sex with this random guy she met that
night. Jessica wasn’t supposed to be at a party, she told her parents she was
spending the night at a friend’s house that night to study for a big test that
was coming up for her class. From her parents knowledge Jessica was still a
virgin. Jessica asked the doctor if he could not tell her parents. The big problem is Jessica has to get treated
for this right away but there is no way to that she could get the medicine for
it without it showing up on their insurance statement. Now she has a dilemma so
should the physician tell the parents or let Jessica get sicker?
I think the doctor is required to treat Jessica based the Hippocratic Oath. Also, the physican is not technically breaking patient confidentality because he never told anyone; he only gave the medicine. The insurance company is the one handing out the information.
ReplyDeleteI do not completely understand this case. Is the situation is that Jessica is refusing treatment because the information will show up on her insurance? I think the physician's duty in this case will be to inform her of the risks of HIV, and then to tell her effects of not getting the medicine she needs.
ReplyDeleteI am also confused. Jessica asked the doctor to not disclose the information to her parents, but she did not refuse treatment. However, if I was in the doctor's shoes I would explain to her that HIV is a life long illness and that her parents would eventually need to know, so she might as well tell them now (especially if they're paying for her medical care). But yes, Rachel, I'm pretty sure he HAS to treat her or at least prescribe her medicine due to the Hippocratic Oath.
ReplyDelete